Preserving our freedom to collect


The Ancient Coin Collectors Guild has become a driving force in the ongoing effort to protect coin collectors and museums in which coins are stored from being forced to give up these items to foreign governments under the premise the coins are the cultural patrimony of the claimant nation. — Richard Giedroyc, World Coin News April 26, 2010



Get the Latest News!

ACCG Donation

Support ancient coin collecting today!

All news

4th Circuit Affirms District Court Ruling in Long Running ACCG Forfeiture Case

The District Court decision in the ACCG forfeiture case was upheld on Appeal. Further action is contemplated.

By Peter K. Tompa |
August 12, 2018

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed (pdf download) the District Court opinion in long running litigation which began when the Ancient Coin Collectors Guild originally sought judicial review of controversial import restrictions on ancient Cypriot and Chinese coins.  This latest case was an action where the government sought to seize through forfeiture the Guild's coins which were originally imported for purposes of that test case.

The initial round of litigation approved the State Department's decision to impose the import restrictions under a very limited "ultra vires" review standard.  Here, the Court ruled that it could also assume major elements of the government's case for forfeiture were established in that earlier decision.  What is disconcerting is that in so doing, the Fourth Circuit panel completely glossed over the Guild's primary argument—that the Court could not assume away major elements of the government's case in the context of a forfeiture action which implicated the Guild's 5th Amendment constitutional due process rights.  This should be particularly troubling because how a court reviews executive action when constitutional rights are at stake was also at the heart of the same court's recent en banc (full court) rulings in the Trump travel ban cases.  That raises the obvious question, are private property and due process rights somehow less important than other constitutional rights?

The Guild intends to seek rehearing to ask the Court to address this fundamental issue.

Facebook Twitter DZone It! Digg It! StumbleUpon Technorati NewsVine Reddit Blinklist Add diigo bookmark

Add a comment
  1. Formatting options